On November 4, 2026, seventeen Elevance Health subsidiaries sued The Perfect Child ABA in New York state court. The complaint alleges roughly $800 million billed since 2021 and more than $160 million paid, and it names the mechanics: patients told the provider was in-network and then shifted to affiliated out-of-network entities, new billing corporations created after the payer put the original entity on pre-payment review, misrepresented place of service and rendering clinician, upcoding, the same claim submitted from several entities, and routine cost-share waivers. A separate federal class action in Tennessee alleges a family was billed $363,816 after their insurer started denying claims.
Whether or not any of it is proven, every payer SIU now has a checklist. ABA providers who do none of these things will still be screened against it.
What pre-payment review actually is
Pre-payment review means the payer holds every claim from your TIN (or a flagged code set) until a reviewer compares the claim to the clinical record. Nothing is denied up front; nothing is paid either. Typical turnaround is 30 to 60 days per claim, records are requested in batches, and anything that does not match is denied with a records-based reason.
For an ABA practice billing weekly, a 45-day hold on all claims is roughly six weeks of revenue frozen at once.
What the complaint tells you payers will screen for
Read as a list of data checks rather than accusations, the Elevance complaint maps to five things a payer can test from the claim alone or from the claim plus notes:
- Rendering provider versus session note. Does the NPI on the claim match the technician or BCBA who signed the note, and does that person hold the credential the code requires (97153 technician, 97155 BCBA, 97151 assessment)?
- Place of service versus the note. Home, clinic, school and telehealth each carry a POS code. A note that says home with a claim that says clinic is the simplest edit a payer can run.
- Units versus documented time. 97153 is billed in 15-minute units. Reviewers add up the start and stop times in the note and compare. A session note with no times is an automatic denial.
- Overlap. The same technician cannot bill two clients at the same hour, and 97155 supervision overlapping 97153 must be documented as concurrent direction, not two separate services.
- Entity consistency. Multiple billing entities under common ownership, especially one appearing after another is put on review, is the pattern this complaint is built on. If you have more than one TIN for legitimate reasons, document why before you are asked.
The part most practices get backwards
The instinct when a payer announces pre-payment review is to argue. The faster path is to make the first batch of records boring. Reviewers remove providers from review when a run of claims matches the notes with nothing to flag; they extend it when records arrive late, incomplete, or with corrections. Treat the first 30 days as an audit you intend to pass, not a dispute you intend to win.
The second mistake is cost-share waivers. Routinely waiving copays and coinsurance for commercial patients is listed in the complaint as an inducement. Hardship waivers with a documented financial assessment are defensible; a blanket policy is not.
Run this on your own claims this month
- Pull 90 days of 97153 and 97155 claims and join them to the session notes. Count mismatches on rendering NPI, place of service, and units versus documented minutes. Fix the templates that produce them before a payer finds them.
- Run an overlap report by technician and by client for the same period. Any two sessions for the same technician that share a minute need a written explanation or a corrected claim.
- List every billing entity, NPI and TIN you submit under, and the reason each exists. If the answer involves a payer action, assume the payer already knows.
Find mismatches and want them worked before a payer does? Tell us. Find none? That is the position you want to be in when the records request arrives.
If you are already on pre-payment review
Three things protect cash. Respond to every records request inside the payer’s window, with the note, the authorization and the credential of the rendering provider in one packet. Keep a log of every claim held, the date records were sent, and the date of decision, because the exit conversation with the payer is won with that log.
And do not open a new entity to bill around the hold. The Elevance complaint exists because someone did.
When this is not the real problem
If your ABA claims are denying before any records request, with CO-197 (no authorization) or CO-151 (units exceed authorized), the issue is authorization management, not pre-payment review. Fix the auth tracking first; it is the same documentation a reviewer will ask for later.
Sources: Behavioral Health Business, “The Perfect Child Sued by Elevance Health over $800M in Fraudulent Billing,” November 6, 2026 (bhbusiness.com). Allegations in a civil complaint are not findings. Confirm each payer’s pre-payment review policy and ABA documentation requirements directly.